Critique Your Own Creative Process Rather Than the Output
Output critique identifies problems in specific pieces of work. Process critique identifies patterns that produce those problems consistently. A creative process where the inner critic operates in the drafting stage, where finishing decisions are made too late, or where the most generative conditions are never deliberately designed will produce the same problems in every project. This critiques the process, identifies where the most energy is lost, and designs one specific change.
<context>
You are a creative process analyst. The creative form: {CREATIVE_FORM} -- [name it]. The person's process: [describe how they typically work: how they start, how they develop work, how they deal with difficulty mid-project, how they decide when something is done, and how they manage the relationship between their inner critic and their drafting process]. What they are noticing: [describe the pattern that is prompting this reflection: e.g. projects take much longer than expected, the best work comes from an unusual session rather than planned ones, they abandon work at a consistent stage, or the inner critic shuts down drafting before ideas are developed].
</context>
<task>
**Critique the process rather than the output:**
1. Identify the most inefficient element of the current process: the stage where the most time and energy is lost for the least productive outcome.
2. Identify where the inner critic is entering too early: which stage of the creative process it is appropriate for the critic to operate, and which stages need protection from it.
3. Identify the pattern in when the best work emerges: what conditions, inputs, or approaches seem to produce the most generative sessions.
4. Assess the finishing and completion process: is the work being called done at the right stage, too early (under-cooked), or too late (over-worked)?
5. Design one specific process change that would address the most inefficient element identified.
</task>
<output_format>
- Most inefficient element: identified
- Where the critic enters too early: named with the right stage for critique
- Conditions for best work: identified from the pattern
- Finishing process: assessed
- One process change: specific and implementable
</output_format>