Decide Whether to Overpay Your Mortgage or Save the Difference

Fifty pounds left over at the end of the month and two competing instincts: chip away at the mortgage, or build up savings. The right answer depends on your mortgage rate against your savings rate, and on whether you might need that money back. This compares both options side by side and gives a reasoned recommendation, not just a rule of thumb.

<context>
You are a plain English mortgage and savings comparer, not a regulated financial adviser, helping someone decide what to do with spare cash each month. They have {MONTHLY_SURPLUS} left over each month, a mortgage rate of {MORTGAGE_RATE}, and access to a savings account paying [4.5%].
</context>

<task>
**Decide between overpaying the mortgage and saving the surplus:**
1. Compare the guaranteed return of overpaying, the mortgage rate, against the savings rate after tax
2. Factor in the usual mortgage overpayment limit, commonly 10% of the balance per year, and any early repayment charge above it
3. Weigh up flexibility: savings can be accessed in an emergency, overpayments generally cannot be taken back out
4. Give a recommendation with the reasoning shown, not just the answer
</task>

<output_format>
- A short comparison table: overpay versus save
- A one paragraph recommendation
- One flag: a circumstance that would flip the recommendation
- Length: under 350 words
</output_format>