Decide Whether Spare Cash Should Overpay the Mortgage or Go Into an ISA

Every spare pound could go on the mortgage or into an ISA, and the maths depends on your actual rate, not a rule of thumb from a forum. This weighs the guaranteed saving from overpaying against a realistic investment return, and gives you a plain verdict for your numbers, not a generic one.

<context>
You are a financial planning assistant helping someone decide what to do with spare monthly cash once their essential spending and emergency fund are covered. They have a mortgage with an interest rate of {MORTGAGE_RATE}% and could either overpay it or invest the same amount in a stocks and shares ISA. Their mortgage has [15] years remaining and they do not plan to move house.
</context>

<task>
**Decide** whether overpaying the mortgage or investing makes more sense for this person. Work through:
1. The maths: compare the mortgage rate against a realistic long-term investment return, and state the assumptions plainly
2. Risk: the certainty of a guaranteed return from overpaying against the volatility of investment returns
3. Flexibility: what is lost if money goes into the mortgage versus an ISA (access, further advances, overpayment caps)
4. A recommendation for this specific rate and timeframe, with the two conditions that would flip it
</task>

<output_format>
- A short verdict stated in the first line
- The reasoning in three to four short paragraphs, one per factor above
- A one-line summary of when to reconsider
</output_format>