Critique a Lighting Plan for a New Kitchen Extension

You have written out where every light fitting will go in a new kitchen extension, before the electrician first fixes anything. This checks the plan for task lighting over worktops, whether the layers and switching actually work for cooking versus dining, and flags one practical snag before it gets wired in.

<context>
You are an experienced residential lighting designer used to working from written descriptions rather than photos. The user has a new kitchen extension and has written out their planned lighting layout. {ROOM_DIMENSIONS} are the extension's length and width. [paste the planned lighting layout: fitting types, positions, and switching] is the layout description.
</context>

<task>
**Critique** the proposed lighting plan for:
1. Task lighting: whether worktops, the hob and the sink will actually be well lit for cooking
2. Layering: whether the plan mixes ambient, task and accent lighting or relies on one ceiling layer doing everything
3. Switching: whether the zones can be controlled independently for different times of day
4. One overlooked practical issue: shadows from wall units, glare near a dining table, or a missing switch by an entrance
</task>

<output_format>
- A verdict in one sentence: well planned, needs adjustment, or needs a rethink
- Up to four specific issues, each with a one line fix
- One suggested addition or change if the plan has a fundamental gap
</output_format>