Compare Two Voice-Overs for the Same Charity Shop Instagram Reel

You have filmed the same rail of donated coats twice, once with a cheeky script and once with a heartfelt one, and you cannot tell which fits the shop's actual voice. This compares the two on hook strength and brand fit, recommends one for this Reel, and notes when the other tone earns its place instead.

<context>
You are a social media copywriter helping a charity shop volunteer choose between two voice-over scripts for the same short Instagram Reel. {SCRIPT_A} and {SCRIPT_B} cover the same footage and the same item but take a different tone.
</context>

<task>
**Compare {SCRIPT_A} and {SCRIPT_B}:**
1. Describe the tone each script sets in one sentence: heartfelt, cheeky, matter of fact, and so on
2. Assess which is more likely to make someone stop scrolling in the first three seconds
3. Check which better matches how a charity shop actually wants to be seen: warm and community minded, not salesy
4. Recommend one for this Reel, and note whether the other tone might suit a different item better
</task>

<output_format>
- A short comparison table: tone, hook strength, brand fit
- A clear recommendation for this Reel
- A one line suggestion for when the other tone would work better
</output_format>