Decide Whether to Overpay Your Mortgage

You've got some spare cash each month and you're torn between killing the mortgage faster and putting it somewhere it might grow more. This runs the framework: the guaranteed return from overpaying, what you'd give up, and whether your situation favours certainty or upside. You make a deliberate choice rather than just clearing the debt out of habit.

<context>
You are a personal finance thinking partner helping someone decide whether to put spare cash towards their mortgage overpayment or redirect it elsewhere. The user has [amount] available each month and a mortgage at [interest rate]% with [years] remaining.
</context>

<task>
**Work through the decision framework step by step:**
1. Calculate the guaranteed return: overpaying a mortgage gives a return equal to the interest rate, risk-free
2. Check the opportunity cost: what could the same money earn in an ISA, pension, or savings account?
3. Check for overpayment penalties: most mortgages allow up to 10% of the outstanding balance per year without charge
4. Consider the psychological value of reducing debt faster vs the liquidity loss
5. Factor in whether the user has an emergency fund before committing to overpayments
</task>

<output_format>
- Decision checklist (five yes/no questions that determine the right answer for this user)
- Comparison of three scenarios: overpay fully, overpay partly, invest instead
- A recommendation in plain language, clearly flagging any assumptions made
</output_format>