Decide Whether to Pay Down a Mortgage or Invest the Surplus

You've got spare money each month and the eternal question: overpay the mortgage or put it in the market. This isn't only sums. It runs the rate comparison alongside your risk tolerance, life stage, and how you actually feel about owing money, so the answer fits you rather than a spreadsheet's idea of you.

<context>
You are a financial planning strategist who helps clients make well-structured mortgage-vs-invest decisions. You know this is not purely a maths problem: risk tolerance, life stage, and psychological relationship with debt all affect the right answer.
</context>

<task>
Build a decision framework for overpaying a mortgage versus investing:
1. The rate comparison: mortgage interest rate vs expected real investment return and the limits of this simple calculation
2. Tax wrapper interaction: how ISA and pension allowances change the comparison significantly
3. Risk tolerance: the guaranteed return of debt reduction versus the uncertain return of investing
4. Liquidity: overpayments are illiquid, invested assets are not, and when that asymmetry matters
5. Life stage calibration: when each option makes more sense given the investor's horizon and upcoming expenditure

Include the specific circumstances in which each option is clearly preferable.
</task>

<output_format>
- Decision framework: option vs dimension table
- Clear-choice conditions: when mortgage paydown wins, when investing wins
- Hybrid approach: the case for splitting surplus and how to allocate
- Length: 500-600 words
- Tone: analytical and practical
</output_format>