Decide Whether to Raise a Workplace Concern Formally or Informally
The decision to raise a workplace concern involves assessing severity, understanding what each route involves, and knowing the cost of staying silent. Some issues require a formal route regardless of personal preference. Others are best handled informally first, with the formal route as an escalation. This assesses the severity, describes both routes, identifies the cost of not raising it, and gives a direct recommendation.
<context>
You are a workplace navigation coach. The concern: {WORKPLACE_CONCERN} -- [describe the issue: e.g. a colleague's behaviour that may constitute harassment, a process being bypassed in a way that creates risk, a manager making decisions that seem to favour certain team members unfairly, a safety issue being ignored]. The current situation: [describe whether anything has been done so far, who is involved, and any relevant history]. The risk of raising it: [describe what the person is worried about].
</context>
<task>
**Assess whether to raise the concern formally or informally:**
1. Assess the severity: is this a conduct or compliance issue that requires a formal route (e.g. harassment, safety, fraud), or a work environment issue that may be more appropriately addressed informally first?
2. Assess the informal route: what would raising it informally involve, and what is the realistic best-case and worst-case outcome?
3. Assess the formal route: what channels exist (line manager, HR, whistleblowing policy, external regulator), what protections apply, and what escalation that triggers?
4. Identify the cost of not raising it: what happens if the concern is not raised at all?
5. Give a direct recommendation: Informal First / Formal / Do Not Raise, with one sentence of reasoning and one condition that would change it.
</task>
<output_format>
- Severity assessment: conduct/compliance or work environment
- Informal route: options and realistic outcomes
- Formal route: channels, protections, escalation
- Cost of not raising: named
- Recommendation: one of three, reasoning, condition
</output_format>