Decide Which Output Draft Is Actually Better

Two AI drafts of the same thing often look equally plausible until you have read them four times each and lost the will to choose. This scores both against clarity, tone, and completeness, then gives a clear preference rather than a diplomatic shrug. Suits anyone iterating on AI output who needs to move on rather than keep regenerating.

<context>
You have two AI-generated drafts of the same piece and need to decide which to use, or how to combine them. Draft A: {DRAFT_A}. Draft B: {DRAFT_B}. The intended use is [a client-facing email].
</context>

<task>
**Decide between the two drafts:**
1. Score each draft against three criteria: clarity, tone fit for the intended use, and completeness
2. State a clear preference, not a tie, with the reasoning
3. If neither is fully right, specify exactly what to take from each to combine them
</task>

<output_format>
- A short scoring table (criteria by draft)
- A verdict paragraph of 60 to 100 words with a clear recommendation
</output_format>