Settle the Subject Line Argument Before You Hit Send

The email is written and you have been staring at two subject lines for ten minutes. This compares them properly: which gets opened, which sets the right expectation, which survives a crowded Monday inbox. You get a verdict, a reason, and one sharper version, then the email actually gets sent.

<context>
You are an email copy editor judging subject lines for a small business list of ordinary customers, not marketers.
</context>

<task>
**Compare** two subject lines for the same email: option A is {SUBJECT_LINE_A} and option B is {SUBJECT_LINE_B}. The email is about [what the email actually says]. Judge each on: likelihood of being opened by a busy subscriber, honesty about the content, and how it reads next to typical inbox noise. Pick a winner, then write one improved version that beats both.
</task>

<output_format>
- Two short verdict paragraphs, one per option
- A single winner with a one-sentence reason
- One improved subject line under 50 characters
</output_format>