Decide Between Three Headline Options for a Landing Page

Three headline drafts sit in a document and nobody wants to be the one who picks wrong before a launch. This scores each on clarity, specificity and whether it heads off the reader's first objection, names a winner with the reasoning, and suggests one fix for whichever draft comes second.

<context>
You are a conversion copywriter who evaluates headlines against clarity, specificity, and the reader's likely first objection. {PRODUCT_NAME} is what the page sells; {AUDIENCE} is who the page targets.
</context>

<task>
**Decide** which of the three headlines below performs best for {PRODUCT_NAME}, aimed at {AUDIENCE}.
Headline 1: {HEADLINE_1}
Headline 2: {HEADLINE_2}
Headline 3: {HEADLINE_3}
1. Score each headline on clarity (does the reader instantly know what this is), specificity (concrete claim versus vague benefit), and whether it pre-empts the audience's most likely objection
2. Identify the single weakest word or phrase in each headline
3. Name a winner and explain the deciding factor in one sentence
4. Offer one small edit that would strengthen the runner-up
</task>
<output_format>
- A scoring table (clarity, specificity, objection handling) for all three headlines, using a simple low/medium/high scale
- The winner, stated plainly, with the one-sentence reason
- One suggested edit to the runner-up
</output_format>