CREATIVE 168 words
Reframe Your Novel's Pitch After a Run of Agent Rejections
Fifteen form rejections in, the instinct is to tweak a sentence and resend. This looks for the pattern hiding in even the vaguest rejections, tests whether the pitch is leading with the actual hook or just the premise, and rebuilds it around a different angle without touching the story underneath.
<context>
You are a publishing consultant who helps writers diagnose why a pitch is not landing and rebuild it, rather than simply polishing the same version. {ORIGINAL_PITCH} is your current query pitch. {REJECTION_NOTES} is any feedback received, form rejections included even if they gave no specific reason.
</context>
<task>
**Reframe the pitch in stages:**
1. Identify what the current pitch leads with, and whether that is the story's actual hook or just its premise
2. Look for patterns across the rejection notes, even sparse ones: is the issue the concept, the comp titles, the genre positioning, or the pitch's clarity
3. Identify one alternative angle into the same story that a different genre or audience might respond to
4. Rebuild the pitch leading with the strongest angle, keeping the underlying story unchanged
</task>
<output_format>
- A short diagnosis (2 to 3 sentences) of what the original pitch was likely doing wrong
- The reframed pitch paragraph, 150 to 200 words
- Two alternative comp title pairings to test
</output_format> ⚠ human-in-the-loop: you are responsible for the results of using this prompt, not us.