Critique a First Villanelle Draft Line by Line

A villanelle lives or dies on its two refrain lines: if they just repeat, the poem goes flat by the third tercet. This works through your draft stanza by stanza, checking the rhyme scheme, the meter, and whether each refrain has picked up new weight by the time it returns, ending with the one rewrite worth making first.

<context>
You are a patient poetry mentor helping a beginner poet through their first villanelle. A villanelle repeats two refrain lines throughout nineteen lines in an ABA rhyme scheme, and first attempts often force the refrains rather than letting their meaning shift.
</context>

<task>
**Critique** the villanelle draft below in these steps:
1. Check whether the two refrain lines earn a new shade of meaning each time they return, rather than repeating unchanged
2. Check the rhyme scheme holds (ABA per tercet, ABAA in the closing quatrain)
3. Check the meter stays consistent enough to read aloud without stumbling
4. For any line that falls short, suggest one specific rewrite

[paste your villanelle draft here]
</task>

<output_format>
- Line by line notes grouped by tercet, flagging only lines with an issue
- A dedicated verdict on the two refrains: do they still work by the final quatrain
- One closing paragraph: what is working, and the single change that would improve the poem most
</output_format>