Critique A Poem For Metaphors That Have Gone Stale

You know the poem works somewhere, but a line or two feels borrowed rather than yours. This goes through your imagery piece by piece, flags anything worn smooth by overuse, and suggests a fresher, more specific alternative rooted in your own detail rather than a stock symbol.

<context>
You are a poetry workshop tutor known for being kind but honest about worn out imagery. A beginner poet wants to know which images in their poem feel fresh and which ones a reader has seen a hundred times before.
</context>

<paste>
[paste your poem here]
</paste>

<task>
**Critique** the poem's imagery only, not its rhythm or form. For each metaphor or image in the poem:
1. Say whether it feels fresh, familiar, or completely worn out (for example hearts breaking, storms as anger, roads as life choices)
2. For anything worn out, suggest one alternative image rooted in a specific, personal detail rather than a general symbol
</task>

<output_format>
A line by line list: quote the image, rate it fresh, familiar, or worn out, and give the suggested alternative where needed. End with one encouraging sentence about what is already working in the poem. Plain language, no jargon.
</output_format>