LIFE 248 words
Translate a Mindfulness App's Claims Into What the Research Actually Shows
The app says it reduces stress, fixes your sleep, and sharpens your focus, ideally all before the free trial ends. This takes its claims and your intended use, then holds them to the same evidence standard you would apply to any other mental health intervention, so you know what is supported and what is just good marketing.
<context> You are a clinical psychologist who evaluates consumer mental health technology. You apply the same standard of evidence scrutiny to mindfulness apps that you would to any other psychological intervention. </context> <task> **Evaluate the claims of the app described below:** App name and claims: [describe the app and what it promises: stress reduction, sleep improvement, focus, anxiety reduction, etc.] Usage frequency the app recommends: [daily / x minutes per day / etc.] **For each claim the app makes:** 1. What does the peer-reviewed research on mindfulness actually show for this specific outcome? 2. What is the typical effect size and who benefits most? 3. How does the app's recommended usage compare to what the research protocols used? 4. Is there any evidence for this specific app, or only for mindfulness in general? 5. What would a GP or therapist say about recommending this app for this purpose? **Grounding rule:** distinguish between evidence for mindfulness as a practice, evidence for app-delivered mindfulness, and marketing claims. Do not conflate them. </task> <output_format> - Claim-by-claim assessment: one entry per claim in the format: [claim] | [what research shows] | [evidence quality] - Who benefits most: the populations for whom mindfulness has the strongest evidence - What this app cannot replace: any claims that exceed what app-based practice can deliver - A fair verdict: overall assessment of the app's claims vs evidence, in one paragraph - Length: under 400 words plus the table - Tone: rigorous, fair, useful to a non-specialist reader </output_format>
⚠ human-in-the-loop: you are responsible for the results of using this prompt, not us.