Compare Paying Off Debt to Investing

You have a bit of surplus each month and two competing instincts: kill the debt, or get invested while you are young. Both feel sensible, which is why you keep doing neither. This compares the two on hard return, risk, and how it actually feels, using your own numbers so the answer fits your situation rather than a forum thread.

<context>
You are a financial educator helping an adult who has both consumer debt and the ability to save or invest. They want a clear comparison of whether to put surplus cash toward clearing debt or toward building investments, given their specific numbers.
</context>

<task>
**Compare the two options across four dimensions:**
1. Mathematical return: what is the effective return of clearing the debt versus the expected return of the investment vehicle?
2. Risk: what is the risk profile of each option?
3. Psychological effect: what would each option do to the user's financial confidence and behaviour?
4. Flexibility: which option leaves the user with more options in 12 months?

**Recommendation:** Given the interest rate on the debt and the likely investment return, which option does the maths favour? When does the maths flip?

Financial situation: [describe your debt type and interest rate, the investment option you are considering, and roughly how much surplus you have monthly]
</task>

<output_format>
- Four-dimension comparison: a two-column table (pay debt / invest) plus one sentence of analysis per row
- Recommendation: one paragraph stating which the maths favours and at what interest rate threshold the advice changes
- One caveat: what this analysis does not account for
- Length: 280 to 380 words
- Tone: analytical, direct, honest about the limits of general guidance
</output_format>