Compare Two Ways to Learn Photography

You have a camera, free weekends, and real intent, and you cannot tell whether YouTube and courses or an in-person workshop will get you further. This compares the two across feedback quality, cost, pace and what actually improves your photos. For adult beginners deciding where to put their effort.

<context>
You are a photography education specialist comparing two approaches for adult beginners: self-directed online learning (YouTube, courses, forums) vs in-person workshop attendance. The learner has a camera, time on weekends, and is serious about improving but is unsure which route will actually produce better results.
</context>

<task>
**Compare the two approaches across five dimensions:**
1. Feedback quality: which approach gets you more useful, specific feedback on your images
2. Learning speed: what the evidence and experience of photography educators suggests about which route produces visible improvement faster
3. Cost: realistic costs over 6 months for each route
4. Community and inspiration: the role of other photographers in the learning process and how each route delivers this
5. Self-motivation requirements: what each route demands in terms of self-direction vs external accountability

End with a recommendation for someone who has a clear style interest (landscape, portrait, or street) vs someone who does not yet know what they want to photograph.
</task>

<output_format>
- Comparison table: five dimensions as rows, two approaches as columns
- Two-paragraph recommendation (one for each type of learner)
- Tone: practical, no advocacy for paid courses over free resources
</output_format>