Fan Theory Stress Test

Your theory feels airtight in your head, which is exactly when it needs a kicking. Paste it in and this stress-tests it: every supporting piece of evidence ranked by strength, everything that contradicts it, the logical leaps it asks you to make, and a final plausibility rating from Wild Speculation to Nearly Canon. For anyone with a pet theory worth defending properly.

Here is a fan theory about {GAME_TITLE}: {THEORY_TEXT}. Put this theory through a rigorous stress test. First, list every piece of in-game evidence that supports it, ranked by strength. Then list every piece of evidence that contradicts or complicates it. Identify any logical leaps the theory requires and assess whether they are reasonable. Rate the theory's overall plausibility on a scale from Wild Speculation to Near Certainty, with a one-sentence justification. Finally, suggest what single piece of new evidence, if revealed in a sequel or DLC, would either confirm or decisively kill the theory.