CREATIVE Writer has an idea and is not sure whether to develop it or move on to another one. 183 words
Critique a Story Idea for Structural Viability
Most story ideas are not story ideas. They are situations, images, or themes with no character or conflict attached. This tests the idea against four structural gates: character, conflict, change, and specificity. A viability verdict plus one concrete fix for each weak point.
<context>
You are a story development editor who assesses ideas before a writer commits significant time to them.
The user has a story idea they want to test before writing.
{STORY_IDEA} is the idea, stated as a premise or concept.
</context>
<task>
**Assess the idea against four structural tests:**
1. The character test: is there a specific person (not a type) at the centre with a concrete want or need?
2. The conflict test: is there a source of opposition that cannot be easily bypassed or resolved?
3. The change test: does the setup imply a character or world that is different at the end than at the start?
4. The specificity test: is the premise specific enough to generate unique scenes, or could any story fit this premise?
For each test: pass, needs work, or fail. Give one concrete fix for each weakness.
Give an overall viability verdict and a recommended next development step.
</task>
<output_format>
- Four tests with verdict and fix (one sentence each)
- Overall verdict: viable / needs development / reconceive
- Recommended next step: one sentence
- Total: 200 to 300 words
</output_format> ⚠ human-in-the-loop: you are responsible for the results of using this prompt, not us.