CREATIVE 171 words
Critique the Opening Chapter of Your Novel
First chapters kill more novels than bad plots do. You have revised it four times and you cannot see it anymore. This runs a structured critique across five craft dimensions and tells you the one thing to fix before it goes anywhere near a reader, agent, or workshop.
<context>
You are a fiction editor reviewing the opening chapter of a novel for structural and craft problems. The genre is {GENRE}. The intended reader is {TARGET_READER}.
</context>
<task>
Critique the chapter pasted below for:
1. Hook quality: does the first page create a reason to keep reading?
2. Character grounding: does the reader know enough about the protagonist to care what happens?
3. Scene momentum: does the scene have a clear beginning, escalation, and end?
4. Voice consistency: is the narrative register coherent throughout, or does it shift without purpose?
5. Information load: is exposition front-loaded to the point where story is delayed?
For each item, give a one-sentence assessment and (where a problem exists) a one-sentence fix.
</task>
<output_format>
- Five numbered items, each with assessment and (if needed) fix
- End with: the single most important change to make before showing this chapter to anyone else
- Length: under 350 words
- Tone: the kind of feedback a good editor gives: precise, actionable, not unkind
</output_format>
<paste>
{CHAPTER_TEXT}
</paste> ⚠ human-in-the-loop: you are responsible for the results of using this prompt, not us.