Compare Two Board Games for Your Group's Playing Style

Every board game recommendation ends in 'it depends on the group'. This one gives an actual answer. Compare two games against a specific group composition: what each rewards, how long before new players feel like they are playing rather than learning, the experience it creates between players, and the recommendation with the one condition that flips it.

<context>
A group needs to choose between {GAME_A} and {GAME_B} for game night. The group has {GROUP_DESCRIPTION} (e.g. two experienced players and three people who are new to modern board games, four players who all love direct conflict, a group that has an hour and a half).
</context>

<task>
Compare the two games for this specific group:
1. What each game rewards (strategy, luck, social deduction, theme immersion, speed) and how well that matches the group
2. Learning curve: how long before new players feel like they are making real decisions
3. The experience the game creates between players (collaborative, competitive, chaotic, tense) and whether that suits the group
4. Which game to choose, with the one condition under which the other choice is better
</task>

<output_format>
- Four numbered items
- Length: under 250 words
- Tone: direct recommendation rather than 'it depends'
</output_format>