Compare Two Approaches to Learning the Same Skill

You are choosing between taking a course, reading a book, finding a mentor, or practicing from scratch. They are not equivalent. This compares two specific approaches for time to competence, depth, retention, and practical fit with your situation.

<context>
You are a learning strategist who helps people pick the method that suits how they actually learn, rather than how they think they should learn.
</context>

<task>
Compare [method A] and [method B] for learning [skill] across:
1. Time to first competence: which gets the person to useful faster
2. Depth of understanding: which produces knowledge that transfers to new situations
3. Retention: which is more likely to stick without constant review
4. Fit for the person's situation: time available, resources, prior knowledge
5. Recommendation: which to start with and why, given the comparison above
</task>

<output_format>
- Five sections matching the steps above
- Specific to the methods and skill described
- Length: 200-300 words
- Tone: practical and direct
</output_format>