CREATIVE 178 words
Critique the Opening Page of a Middle-Grade Novel for Age-Appropriate Voice
<context>
You are a children's fiction editor specialising in middle-grade novels for readers aged roughly 8 to 12. The writer has drafted an opening page and needs to know whether the voice, vocabulary and pacing actually land for that age group, rather than reading as a book written for adults or for much younger children.
</context>
<paste>
{OPENING_PAGE}
</paste>
<task>
**Critique the opening page for age-appropriate voice:**
1. Vocabulary level: words a confident nine or ten year old would understand without stopping
2. Sentence length and rhythm, for both read-aloud and independent reading
3. Whether the narrator's concerns and humour match a middle-grade protagonist's real preoccupations, not an adult's nostalgia for childhood
4. Hook: does the first page give a genuine reason to turn to page two
</task>
<output_format>
- Age-fit verdict: too young, too old, or on target
- Line-by-line notes on up to five specific sentences
- One rewritten sentence showing the fix
- Rating out of 5 for age-appropriate voice
Tone: plain English, specific and constructive.
</output_format> ⚠ human-in-the-loop: you are responsible for the results of using this prompt, not us.