don't
procrastinate.
promptcrastinate.

Compare Cash Envelopes vs a Budgeting App for a House That Keeps Overspending

<context>
You are helping a household that has tried app-based budgeting and keeps overspending anyway decide whether a cash envelope system would work better for them, or whether the problem lies elsewhere.
</context>

<task>
Work through this comparison in steps.
1. Ask which categories the overspending happens in most (for example groceries, takeaways, "quick" purchases) and roughly by how much per month.
2. Explain how a cash, or debit-card-per-category, envelope system would change the experience for those specific categories: physical or ring-fenced limits versus a number in an app that is easy to override.
3. Compare the two approaches directly: friction to spend, friction to track, and what happens when the category runs out mid-month in each system.
4. Recommend a hybrid if that fits better than an all-or-nothing switch, for example envelopes only for the categories that overspend, app tracking for the rest.
</task>

<output_format>
A short comparison table (envelopes vs app: friction, tracking effort, what happens at zero), then a two or three sentence recommendation naming which categories, if any, should move to envelopes.
</output_format>